This post was inspired by a conversation on the RRC forums about scary movies.
As a boy growing up in Dayton, Ohio, I spent many a Saturday evening (or afternoon) watching a show called “Shock Theater” which featured schlocky horror movies and was hosted by Dayton’s own “Dr. Creep“.

I remember one of the films distinctly, not because it was particularly good or scary–it wasn’t–but because my father scared the shit out of me during the movie. The film was called The Manster. The premise was too convoluted for a young boy to understand. In the movie, the protagonist, also known as “The Guy,” starts to grow a second head for some reason (Read the Wiki link if you want to know the actual reason. I certainly didn’t remember it.) The second head begins as an irritation on the guy’s shoulder. In one of the key scenes, the guy scratches the spot on his shoulder that is driving him nuts only to reveal an EYE sprouting there! So, that part did scare me.

My father was watching the movie with me and noticed my being visibly startled by the eye on the guy’s shoulder. This must have been during the afternoon because dad was wearing his blue, terry-cloth robe (he worked third shift, so he wouldn’t wake up until early afternoon on the weekends) and mom was in the bathroom putting on make-up. Engrossed in the movie, I didn’t notice dad slip into the bathroom with my mom and close the door. I didn’t notice him come back out a few minutes later, either.
I did notice when he started to groan a bit, as if he were in pain. I turned my attention back to the movie. Dad groaned a little more. Apparently, the pain was getting worse. I looked at him and watched as he rubbed his shoulder. I didn’t think much of it and turned back to the movie once more. Dad got off the couch and stood next to the television, grimacing in agony. He cried out in terrible pain. I began to get concerned. Both my sister and I watched as he grabbed the collar of his robe, let out a horrific wail, then ripped the collar off his shoulder to reveal–AN EYE!
“AAAAAHHHHHGHH!” my dad bellowed.
“AAAAAHHHHHGHH!” my sister and I screamed as we levitated off the floor.
“AAAAAHHHHHGHH!” my dad screamed again.
“AAAAAHHHHHGHH!” my sister and I screamed as we ran out of the room.
Dad chased us–all of us screaming–until he cornered us in our bedroom. He stopped screaming and started laughing. He then revealed to us that the “eye” on his shoulder was drawn on by my mother using eyebrow pencil.
I’d say this was the last time my dad scared the shit out of us, but I’d be lying.